The most notorious scientific feud in history - Lukas Rieppel
- 1,045,737 Views
- 2,423 Questions Answered
- TEDEd Animation
In this TED-Ed lesson, we have tried to take a broader view of the subject and ask what the Bone Wars can teach us about the relationship between science and capitalism during the American Gilded Age. If you are interested in learning more about that complex and controversial topic, you might like Lukas Rieppel’s book Assembling the Dinosaur. Many of the big ideas that informed this lesson are explored in much greater depth and detail there. If you want a shorter article on the same theme, you might like his essay “On America’s Wild West of Dinosaur Hunting,” or one about “How Dinosaurs Became Tyrants of the Prehistoric.”
One part of the story that is especially worthy of further study, thought, and reflection is the important role that Native Americans guides played in the discovery of dinosaurs and other prehistoric monsters during the nineteenth century. Regrettably, much less has been written on that topic, with the notable exception of Adrienne Mayor’s book, Fossil Legends of the First Americans. However, there is no shortage of books that will teach you more about the history of American imperialism, westward expansion, and Native American dispossession. An excellent overview of the topic is Patricia Limerick’s classic survey, The Legacy of Conquest. Those who would like to learn more about how the long history of American imperialism continues to impact indigenous communities will enjoy Our History is the Future by Nick Estes.
Finally, the Bone Wars should force us to confront some thorny questions about the relationship between science and capitalism. Traditionally, members of the scientific community jealously guarded their autonomy for fear that base economic motives might threaten their claim to be engaged in a purely disinterested pursuit of objective truth. A fascinating but dense and sophisticated book about the way scientists in seventeenth century Europe first sought distance themselves from the world of commerce is Steven Shapin’s A Social History of Truth. Harold Cook tells a very different story in Matters of Exchange, which argues that science and capitalism have always been deeply entangled with one another. Still, many of us remain committed to the idea that scientific research ought to be free from the corrupting influence of the profit motive. And, as Naomi Oreskes and Erik Conway point out in Merchants of Doubt, we have good reason to be suspicious of skeptical claims about climate change made by scientists whose research has been paid for by petroleum companies.
Create and share a new lesson based on this one.