Skip to main content

The case of the missing fractals - Alex Rosenthal and George Zaidan

  • 681,093 Views
  • 3,674 Questions Answered
  • TEDEd Animation

Let’s Begin…

A bump on the head, a mysterious femme fatale and a strange encounter on a windswept peak all add up to a heck of a night for Manny Brot, Private Eye. Watch as he tries his hand at saving the dame and getting the cash! Shudder at the mind-bending geometric riddles! Thrill to the stunning solution of The Case of the Missing Fractals.

Create and share a new lesson based on this one.

About TED-Ed Animations

TED-Ed Animations feature the words and ideas of educators brought to life by professional animators. Are you an educator or animator interested in creating a TED-Ed Animation? Nominate yourself here »

Meet The Creators

Additional Resources for you to Explore
The word “fractal” was coined by Benoit Mandelbrot (namesake of both the Mandelbrot set and a certain hard-nosed private eye) in 1975. Mandelbrot was not the first mathematician to examine these perplexing shapes, but he launched the formal study of them as a scientific tool to understand complexities found in nature. His book, The Fractal Geometry of Nature paved the way in this regard.
For a straightforward, illustrated guide to fractals, you can check out Introducing Fractal Geometry.
NOVA documentary about fractals that includes interviews with Benoit Mandelbrot.
A great explanation of how the Mandelbrot set is generated.
You can use this program to generate and explore fractals.
A music video rendition of Jonathan Coulton’s Mandelbrot Set
A more complete definition of fractals than the one found in this video is:
- Fractals are generated through iteration (repeating the same operation infinitely)
- Fractals display self similarity (they’re repeat the same patterns no matter how much you zoom in)
- Fractals have fractional Hausdorff dimension. Essentially, this means that they’re rougher than platonic solids—more jagged and with fewer smooth, predictable curves. If you were to walk through a thicket of fractals, they’d stick to your clothes a lot more than spheres and cubes would.
This Wikipedia page lists quite a few fractals in increasing order of Hausdorff dimension.
Imagine a two-dimensional world -- you, your friends, everything is 2D. In his 1884 novella, Edwin Abbott invented this world and called it Flatland. Alex Rosenthal and George Zaidan take the premise of Flatland one dimension further, imploring us to consider how we would see dimensions different from our own and why the exploration just may be worth it.
TED-Ed
Lesson Creator
New York, NY
Why do fractals appear in nature so often?
Benoit Mandelbrot, namesake of the Mandelbrot set and all-around fractal pioneer, observed that “clouds are not spheres, mountains are not cones, coastlines are not circles, and bark is not smooth, nor does lightning travel in a straight line.” In fact, fractals can be found all over the natural world—some examples include the nautilus shell, Romanesco Broccoli, and the coastline of Great Britain.
04/29/2014
Avatar for Makarand Hazarika
Makarand Hazarika • COMPLETED LESSON

I haven't put any thought to it whatsoever. So my answer is going to be as shallow as probably any answer can get. In nature, things don't get created in one straight simple process. The processes get repeated. Take the Sun for example. It wasn't created right after the Big Bang. The primitive stars were full of Hydrogen and didn't have enough materials to form complex things such as life. They died and new elements were created at their core and new stars were born out of their death. This process got repeated again and again. And it wasn't just one single process. The creation process was a sum of many different processes which themselves were composed of other processes and so on. When things get repeated again and again and again and again in time, and if it leaves a pattern in space, I guess you get fractals.

04/30/2014
Avatar for Bethany Diegelman
Bethany Diegelman • COMPLETED LESSON

"As above, so below. As within, so without." ...I think that's how it goes.

The way I think of it, if the universe is perpetually expanding, wouldn't it make sense that everything within it must also expand? The whole bang thing is a fractal!

...I'm feeling a little dizzy now.

05/01/2014
Avatar for Beatrice Pearl
Beatrice Pearl • COMPLETED LESSON

As natural selection tries to make living things more efficient, once it finds a perfect solution, it won't want to deviate from it. It's like finding the perfect chocolate chip cookie recipe- after so much trial and error, why would you choose anything but the most optimal recipe? And, if that one solution works for multiple things, hey, that works.

I'm actually very interested by Makarand's answer. I've never really thought of fractals that way before. I wonder if once the solution that's "just right" is found, it's used as a baseline- like how after learning basic drawing skills, artists will deviate from it, but always have that similarity. Each deviation would then have to find ITS own perfect solution, and then deviate, so it forms a repeating pattern. Huh.

05/04/2014
Avatar for Elizabeth Solis
Elizabeth Solis • COMPLETED LESSON

This is another interesting subject that provokes us to think about infinity. I enjoyed all the comments posted previous to this. I think they all add some good insight to this subject relatively new to me. Makarand speaks about how the big band is sort of a fractal. With the aid of technology we are now able to study the 'infinite' space of the universe and atoms. So far, through our limitations we have perceived nature in duality night and day, male and female, me and you. Maybe these type of structures will entice our consciousness to think differently. How we are all part of something bigger.

05/15/2014
Avatar for Samantha Cruz
Samantha Cruz • COMPLETED LESSON

I think that Fractals appear often in nature because when things grow, they grow by duplicating cells. We know that people start off as one cell, but then continuously duplicate until they become multiple-celled beings. This duplication process is something that happens in all different organisms in nature. This is why it makes sense for many things, when magnified, show smaller versions of the larger organism.

04/06/2015

Customize This Lesson

Create and share a new lesson based on this one.

About TED-Ed Animations

TED-Ed Animations feature the words and ideas of educators brought to life by professional animators. Are you an educator or animator interested in creating a TED-Ed Animation? Nominate yourself here »

Meet The Creators