Skip to main content

TED-Ed

Can you outsmart the fallacy that divided a nation? - Elizabeth Cox

961,732 Views

2,382 Questions Answered

TEDEd Animation

Let’s Begin…

It’s 1819. The US is preparing to make Missouri and Maine new states. One representative insists that slavery shouldn’t be allowed in any new state. Another believes it should be a state’s right to choose. A compromise is proposed: slavery will be allowed in Missouri and prohibited in Maine. Can you spot the problem with this compromise? Elizabeth Cox explores the middle ground fallacy.

Additional Resources for you to Explore

A logical fallacy is simply an error in logic. For example, a middle ground fallacy illogically equates two extreme views, such as anti-slavery and pro-slavery, as equally valid. We have learned that if one view is wrong, while the other is correct, a compromise between the two is still wrong. The midpoint between two opposing views is not always the truth.

Watch episodes from TED-Ed’s Logical Fallacies series here to see if you can outsmart common fallacies!

The Missouri Compromise and the American Civil War shows us that the use of faulty logic or reasoning has the potential for centuries of devastating and enduring consequences. The stage was set for the Missouri Compromise long before 1820. The first enslaved Africans arrived in Jamestown, Virginia in 1619, more than 150 years before the Declaration of Independence, and over 240 years before the Emancipation Proclamation.

Pulitzer Prize winner, Nikole Hannah-Jones conceived The 1619 Project to chronicle the history of slavery, it’s continued impact on our culture, and to celebrate the role of formerly enslaved peoples in defining American democracy. Take a look at this short film to get an idea of how systematic fallacies can perpetuate centuries of oppression and affect all of our daily lives.


About TED-Ed Animations

TED-Ed Animations feature the words and ideas of educators brought to life by professional animators. Are you an educator or animator interested in creating a TED-Ed Animation? Nominate yourself here »

Meet The Creators

Educator
Elizabeth Cox
Director
Hector Herrera, Pazit Cahlon
Narrator
Jack Cutmore-Scott
Animator
Hector Herrera
Art Director
Hector Herrera
Storyboard Artist
Pazit Cahlon
Sound Designer
Nick Sewell
Music
Massassauga
Director of Production
Gerta Xhelo
Editorial Director
Alex Rosenthal
Producer
Bethany Cutmore-Scott
Editorial Producer
Elizabeth Cox
Content Associate
Abdallah Ewis
Special Thanks
Alicia Lane

More from The Demon of Reason